West Ada Math Symposium

Oh, hey there!  It’s been a minute since I last wrote and figured it was time to dust off this old blog and bring it back to life.  The last couple of years have been a whirlwind of new adventures, challenges and successes.  I’m excited to share the highlights with you!

You guys…I landed my dream job.  I’m the Coordinator for Math Curriculum & Instruction in the largest district in Idaho:  West Ada School District.  I oversee all the math curriculum, resources, and instruction that takes place in kindergarten through 12th grade classrooms.  

We serve just about 40,000 students and 2,100 teachers across 58 schools.  The next largest district in our state is half our size.  And because I know you’re numbers people, this equates to about 750 elementary teachers and 200 secondary math teachers that I have the honor of supporting.

As you can imagine, moving a system this large, instructionally, is a challenge.  We often describe it as sailing a ship. We literally can’t change course quickly; it takes time, courage, patience, and a plan.

Thankfully, the captain of our ship is an inspirational instructional leader.  Our superintendent, Dr. Derek Bub, is a visionary that is experienced, knowledgeable, and compassionate.  His compass always points towards kids. He’s the same leader I wrote about in this blog many, many years ago.  So, when I say I would follow him to the moon, I mean it.  I admire that Dr. Bub listens with intention, draws his power from relationships, and encourages the people around him to dream big. 

The Big Math Project

Within days of starting my new job Dr. Bub called me into his office and asked, “What if…” and began the conversation that would become our beloved West Ada Math Symposium.  What I hope to share with you now is how we strengthened a culture of learning among the math teachers in our district through the Math Symposium.

We wanted to turn the ship.  We wanted to provide consistent and impactful professional learning that would have a greater return on investment than, say, sending a few teachers to a conference.  And we wanted to use our ESSER funds to invest in our teachers, not in things.

Then, we started to *dream*.  We started to brainstorm the names of the most influential math educators that we have learned from over the years.  Dr. Bub and I both came from Southern California where we were surrounded by brilliant math minds that would flock to Southern California for conferences such as NCTM and CMC-South. 

Robert Kaplinsky and Fawn Nguyen immediately came to mind. Dan Meyer, Sara Van der Werf, Howie Hua, Chris Luzniak, Geoff Krall, Mike Flynn, Graham Fletcher, Matt Vaudrey… Our list was not short. And for once, neither was our budget. It was the perfect storm to create something amazing: We had the vision, I had the connections, and we had the funding! We got to work and built the West Ada Math Symposium.

The Math Symposium

Our Math Symposium was a series of 10 full-day workshops, held on one Saturday per month, each featuring a different math educator. We initially invited only one teacher from each of our 58 schools to participate in the Math Symposium.  Our original budget would only allow for this many but through the generosity of our Superintendent and our school board we were able to accept everyone who applied (96 teachers).  We asked these teachers to commit to attending at least 9 out of the 10 Saturdays and we would honor their time with a $5,000 stipend, paid through ESSER funds, at the end of the series.

In addition to attendance, teachers also complete a reflection assignment that we called a, “TIY” or “Try it Yourself” for each Math Symposium they attended.  We asked teachers to take what they learned and try something with their students.  Their assignment included an opportunity to reflect on what went well and what they would do differently next time.  We also asked teachers to submit evidence like student work samples, pictures or video of their classrooms, or their detailed lesson plans.

The TIY Assignment

There really were 3 reasons why we asked teachers to complete a TIY assignment:

First, we wanted teachers to take what they learned and try something in hopes that maybe 1 or 2 things “stick.”  We were very realistic, from the beginning, that everything a teacher learns over the course of 10 Saturday’s won’t stick

…but if we could get at least 1 thing to stick it would have been worth it.  Almost 100 teachers shifting their practice in at least one way–that’s a win in our book.

Second, we needed to hold teachers accountable for the stipend they would be earning.  It was an easy way to assess their attendance, what they learned, and how they put it into practice.  

Third, having those completed reflections made it real easy to provide evidence of impact to our district leaders and board members—we had teacher written reflections and pictures to share every month!

The Lineup of Speakers

At the start, we asked teachers what they wanted to learn more about and who they wanted to learn from.  We got a few suggestions but for the most part we knew we wanted to change hearts and minds around math education in our district so that influenced who we invited.  We were so fortunate to have a powerhouse line up of speakers.  And honestly, there were so many more that we wanted to invite but we ran out of Saturdays!  Trust us, we’re already dreaming about Math Symposium 2.0. 

There was definitely a bit of celebrity involved.  I mean, our teachers were using Dan Meyer’s Google Sheet of 3-Act Tasks for a while but to have the man himself come work with our teachers was a once in a lifetime experience for some…and the first time some teachers learned about a little thing called Desmos

Chris Luzniak came to work with our teachers and as a result invited one of our math coaches to be on his Debate Math podcast!  Not only did we get to learn from Chris but now we’re building capacity and expanding horizons for a teacher that might have gone her whole career not learning about Debate Math. 

It was so cool when Fawn Nguyen was with us working on visual patterns and learning about rich math tasks.  Our teachers have seen Graham Fletcher’s progression videos and know of him.  When Fawn mentioned his name, there was an audible gasp in the room when I said, “Graham’s coming in October”! 

The most beautiful part of the line up is that each speaker reinforced what previous speakers taught and often alluded to learning that would happen in a future Math Symposium.  Teachers are making powerful connections because of consistent and continued opportunities to learn. 

Top: Robert Kaplinsky and Graham Fletcher
Bottom: Chris Luzniak, Dan Meyer, Fawn Nguyen

The Outcomes

When we take a step back and reflect on the impact our Symposium has had on our teachers, we can narrow it down to 3 powerful elements.  And don’t worry, a big budget isn’t one of them.  We believe, whether you have a big budget or no budget, if Professional Learning contains these 3 elements it will be impactful learning that shifts hearts and minds in the right direction.

First, Professional Learning should have a “Learn-Try-Reflect” structure. It was so powerful that our Symposium was structured so that teachers learned something, then tried it out, and then reflected.  We encouraged teachers to be brave and take a risk.  In the words of Matt Vaudrey, we made failure cheap.

Second, Professional Learning is more impactful when teachers are inspired to transfer the knowledge to others. We created this excitement around learning that made it feel a little exclusive. Remember how we originally said we only wanted 1 per building? The exclusive feeling has led to teachers wanting to share what they learned because they know they were the “only one” from their building that could come. A highlight for Dr. Bub has been walking into buildings and seeing an entire PLC incorporating the same instructional strategies that one teacher learned from Math Symposium.

Moreover, teachers often only work with teachers in their building (or within their own PLCs) and this created the opportunity to collaborate with teachers from different schools.

Third, create focused and frequent Professional Learning opportunities. Districts are often accused of having too many initiatives which cause teachers to feel pulled in different directions.  All the ideas are great ideas but it feels unfocused and overwhelming.  Revisiting learning regularly throughout the year and adding on keeps the learning alive and can create a lasting impact.  It’s not a new initiative or one more thing.  It’s spiraled and scaffolded.  

We realized we had built something special when teachers returned, month after month, not only learning more but reinforcing what they had already learned.  This focus allowed teachers to make powerful connections with their learning each month.  

The Impact

We have seen a difference in our teachers as a result of our Math Symposium and the support of our Superintendent, district leaders, and school board.  We used to think of school as reading, writing, spelling…and math.  Math is now included.  Math is a priority for the whole district and that’s helped the culture to shift.  And everyone is talking about it–teachers, building leaders, district leaders. 

West Ada Math Teachers at the Math Symposium

How can you build a culture of learning?

We were so blessed with the opportunity to create the West Ada Math Symposium and my hope is to encourage you to build something that builds a culture of learning among math teachers around you.  

Lead a book study that includes a schedule with follow up meetings and discussions.  Create opportunities for teachers to apply their learning, share with others, and reflect on their practice.

Send teachers to a math conference and create an opportunity to share, apply, and reflect.  Encourage teachers to be brave and take a risk in their classrooms!  Make failure cheap!

Invite one keynote speaker to work with your teachers.  They’re more affordable than you probably think and you can never duplicate the inspiration and excitement that naturally comes from a guest speaker!  Then, ask that speaker to connect with teachers a few times during the school year to extend the learning.  Every speaker we have invited to our Math Symposium were more than willing to connect and extend the learning.

We reflect back on why teachers initially signed up and what things they asked to learn about.  Teachers really didn’t know what they didn’t know.  That conversation has changed.  Teachers are now equipped with promising practices in math education, finding ways to incorporate them in their teaching, and inspiring others!

The ship is moving.

Stay tuned for Math Symposium 2.0!

-PV

PS–None of this could have been possible without my amazing team of Math Coaches. We’ve been told by many that West Ada is the gold standard in hospitality, logistics, and efficiency. And it’s all because of them. Thank you Amanda, Kip, Sarah, and Tricia.

PSS–To all of our speakers that flew to Idaho to work with our teachers. Your time and talent has made a huge impact on learning in our district and we are forever grateful for the hearts and minds you changed. We hope you’ll consider working with us again. Stay tuned for your invite to Math Symposium 2.0!

Debate Math!

Last weekend I attended the CPM Teacher Conference in San Francisco, CA.  It was a fantastic experience to not only be there but to also present a workshop and speak at the Ignite session–but more on that later.

One highlight of the weekend was attending Chris Luzniak‘s session on Debate Math.  In his presentation, Chris describes that an argument consists of 2 answers:  a claim and a warrant.  Then, when asking a mathematical question, Chris instructs his students to use this sentence frame to state their argument:

“My claim is __________________,

and my warrant is _________________.”

He began the session with some fun, non-math questions that we debated:

  • What’s the best TV show?  

My argument:  My claim is Friends is the best TV show, and my warrant is that the writing is very witty and the actors play their parts so well.

  • The most important thing I want my students to learn is ___?  

My argument:  My claim is that I want my students to learn that every one of them can do math, and my warrant is that hard work pays off.

Then Chris began asking us math related questions and continued to have us debate using the same routine of argument = claim + warrant.  As I listened to people’s arguments, I tried to imagine what it would look like to implement this in my classroom with my students.  Then, Chris puts up this slide:

img_5506.jpg

I was sold!  I thought about how many times I had tried to get my students to understand how to write 2-column proofs in Geometry with no real success and unfortunately, most teachers I’ve collaborated with regarding this topic haven’t had anything as exciting as this.  And I couldn’t have asked for better timing as my lesson plans for the following week included flow chart proofs on congruent triangles in Integrated Math 1 and 2-column proofs of properties of quadrilaterals in Integrated Math 2.

I got home from the conference and got to work right away!


Day 1:  The Monday after the conference we happened to have a minimum day so it was the perfect amount of time to introduce the debate structure to my students.  I used this slide deck in Integrated Math 2 and had them practice using the sentence frame with non-math topics and then a few easy math questions.  I followed Chris’ debate structure including asking students to stand while making their argument.

IMG_5545

The most surprising thing was that the students that typically don’t participate or engage much were the ones debating the most!  I had students that never want to take notes or do any math during class *jumping* out of their seats to make an argument.


Day 2:  In Integrated Math 1 we began a unit on congruent triangles.  We had really only done the first lesson where my students learned that 2 figures are congruent if (1) there is a series of rigid transformations that maps one object onto the other and (2) all the corresponding angle and side measures are congruent.  So, I began the next lesson with this slide deck (remember that I had already spent the day before going over the structure and sentence frame). 

 

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The question was “Are the shapes congruent?” and my students, just on day 2, already knew to stand up and use the sentence frame, “My claim is…, and my warrant is…”  All the slides led to the reinforcement that all corresponding angle and side measures must be equal for the shapes to be congruent.  The last slide in the deck was this one:

IMG_5552

For this one, students needed to calculate missing angle measures using the Triangle Angle Sum Theorem and calculate the missing side lengths with Pythagorean Theorem.  As they found missing measurements, my students stood and clearly argued how they found each missing angle measure and side length:

“My claim is the missing angle is 20.61 degrees, my warrant is the sum of the 3 angles is 180 so if I add 69.39 and 90 together, then subtract from 180 I get the missing angle [measure].”

“My claim is the missing side length is 125 feet, my warrant is when I use Pythagorean Theorem, 44 squared plus 117 squared equals c squared…then I take the square root and get 125 feet.”

This was a great way to open the lesson and get them primed for the triangle congruence conditions. They had already argued clearly what it meant for triangles to be congruent and they were ready to discover the shortcuts to determining triangle congruence (SSS, SAS, ASA, AAS, and HL).  


One of the Standards of Mathematical Practice tell us that students should be able to construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others (SMP3).  The structure of Debate Math helps students do just that!  

As I listened to my students make their arguments, I realized even more reasons why I love Debate Math:

  • Having to say their idea around the words “claim” and “warrant” made them instantly elevate their vocabulary and use of academic language.
  • Students making their argument spoke slowly, clearly, and with authority.
  • Students were listening, not just respectfully, but intently to each other;  making sure they used the sentence frame properly and checking that their warrants were solid and valid.

And things just keep getting better:  Days 3 and 4 we were writing flow chart proofs and the words claim and warrant felt more organic to the process than teaching them to use the traditional language of “statements” and “reasons”. 

Needless to say I’m so excited to get to 2-column proofs!  Wow, did I really just say that?!

~PV~

 

Circus Animal Cookies: Predictions, Association, and Line of Best Fit

I teach Integrated Math 1 and during a Team meeting we were looking for ways to start a new unit on modeling two-variable data.  We knew we wanted the first lesson to set a positive tone for a new unit being introduced during a time of year when we are starting to get tired.  Like, is it winter break yet?

This first lesson needed to:

  • Remind students how to take data and transform it into a scatter plot
  • Remind students how to describe the association of the scatter plot
  • Review how to draw a line of best fit they feel best models the data and then write the equation of that line
  • And most importantly (well, for me anyway) be fun and memorable for our students!

We are blessed to have a department of math teachers that happily collaborate and share their cool stuff so we immediately turned to our resident statistician, Ricky Yip.  He teaches our AP Statistic classes and we had a feeling he had something good.

We were right!  Ricky shared with us that he uses Circus Animal Cookies for a similar lesson.  Our team took his idea and ran with it.  We built a lesson around our students working collaboratively to collect data and discover the math.


Here’s how the lesson goes:

We start with students sitting in teams of 4 and we give each student a small, snack sized bag of Circus Animal Cookies.  Already, we are off to a great start because who doesn’t love cookies?

img_4333.jpg

Problem #1:  Students are asked to examine their bag of Circus Animal Cookies and predict how many cookies they have and how many pink versus white cookies are in their bag.  Then they get to open their bag of cookies and see if their prediction was correct!

Circus Animal Cookie Drop

Problem #2:  After each member of their team has recorded their data (pink versus white cookies) students represent their data on a dot plot.  My colleague, Adam Varnes, took this opportunity to bring up students’ work to display and discuss domain and range of the data.

IMG_4553

Problem #3:  At this time students are instructed to collect data from all the other teams in the room.  In my class, I have 9 teams, and each student has a role.  Each team has a Reporter so I asked each of them to write their team’s data on the board for all to copy.  Students take the class data and create a scatter plot.

IMG_4351

Problem #4:  This problem gives an opportunity for students to review how to describe the association of a graph:  form, direction, strength, and outliers.  After describing our Circus Animal Cookie scatter plot, students realize that the data could be modeled with a line.  Students draw a best fit line and share their strategies with how to draw it with the class.  Students are asked to explain what the slope and y-intercept represented in the context of this problem and then write the equation of the best fit line.

Closure:  We wrap up the lesson with a Whiparound.  I ask each team of students to share one thing they learned today with the class.  When I call on their team, the Reporter is the one who shares for the team.  Students aren’t allowed repeats so they must share something new.  As they share, I compose a list on the board of their responses;  making sure to focus the discussion on how to describe the association of the scatter plot and how to find the equation of the best fit line.


If you’re interested in running this lesson, here’s the handout we gave to our students:  Circus Animal Cookies Lesson   I’d love to hear about how the lesson went for you and what improvements you made!

We are so pleased with this lesson and how well our students responded to it!  In fact, there were several times during class that I thought my students were off task because they seemed to be enjoying themselves too much!  Much to my delight, when I questioned them on their work they answered both correctly and with confidence.

A fun and memorable lesson for our students—check!

~PV~

An Open Letter to my Seniors

Statistical Reasoning in Sports;  my first thoughts were, “Um….I’m not a sports person (like, at all) and statistics is my least favorite of all the maths (because I was not great at it).”

Perfect.

After the initial shock, I realized that teaching Sports Stats (as we called it) was just another challenge for me to overcome.  I knew it would make me a better teacher, it would strengthen my math skills, and I would probably learn some sports along the way. And let’s be honest, I finally landed my dream job, at my dream school so I wasn’t going to say no.

Challenge accepted.  I knew the Stats.  You knew the sports.  I prayed we’d help each other get through the year.

Blog Pic_Seniors

As the year went on we did just that;  I taught you some stats and you answered my endless questions about sports.  We learned about the “hot hand”, hypotheses testing, winning streaks and losing streaks.  We rejected things;  we failed to reject things (whatever that meant?!).  We even did a March Madness bracket based on statistical concepts we learned.  All along the way you taught me bits and pieces of sports based on your experiences playing and watching games.  We always had someone in the room that knew about swim, or football, or softball, or golf;  so someone always patiently answered my questions.

Here we are at the end of the school year; the end of your fourth year at our school.  You have all worked so hard for this moment which is evident in the list of impressive college acceptances and even more inspiring future goals.  And even though we’ve spent an entire school year together, the time has just slipped by and now here we are at the end.

FASTBALL_FEATUREIMAGE-640x320-1

We watched the baseball documentary, Fastball.  I was moved.  I had no idea how elegant the game of baseball is;  the dance between a pitcher and a hitter (the guy with the bat is called a hitter, right?) requires so much skill, finesse, and of course math.  This was the moment.

Suddenly, I was very aware of all the baseball players in our class and what positions they play and all of a sudden now I know that the pitcher is a big deal, and the catcher is a big deal, and all of a sudden I knew that everyone that has  to hit that baseball with a bat is a BIG. DEAL.

All the bits and pieces of sports you have been sharing with me started flooding into my mind.  

Then I started to wonder about all of you, and the sport you humbly said you played.  You don’t just play football, you’re the captain, aren’t you?  You’re not just on the basketball team, you brought our team to the CIF Championships, right?  You don’t just play volleyball, you’re playing in college on a scholarship because you’re that good, huh? Wait, I saw you at the signing ceremony in the gym because you are a star softball player. Then I started to wonder more…that wasn’t just some random pair of shoes you were painting, or dance you were performing, or song you were singing, was it?  Hold on, that’s YOUR painting on display in the Art Show?  That was YOU up on stage at the Pop Show?  

That was the moment it all clicked for me. It just clicked. I didn’t get a chance to know you.  I didn’t get a chance to really get to know how amazing you are.  All of that is just starting to unfold for me and I’ve only got a couple more minutes with you before you go off into the world and do amazing things.  For the first time I am starting to see you clearly.  You are the captains of Varsity teams.  You are the starting player at each of your games.  You are athletes.  You are award winning artists, musicians, singers, dancers, philanthropists, entrepreneurs, and leaders.  I am so blessed to have taught you.  What a privilege it has been to be your teacher! I know, for a fact, that you taught me far more than I taught you this year.  And for that, I’ll always be grateful and I’ll never forget any of you.

I don’t want you to leave yet, but I know you must.

Your last year here was my first year and I finally feel like I have my bearings;  I can finally stop and take a look around.  And I know I don’t know some of you at all.  We didn’t spend a lot of time together.  I didn’t find the time to get to know you.  I just want you to know that I see you just as clearly as I do anyone else in our class.  And I wish I had more time with you.

Be brave.  Do amazing things, even if they scare you (like teaching Statistical Reasoning in Sports scared me!).  You’ll learn and grow from each of those experiences in the most rewarding ways.  

Thank you for a great year,

Mrs. Vandenberg

Dear “…stuffed-shirt, overpaid, abstracted Educator…”

Last weekend was the California Mathematics Council’s southern conference, CMC South, held in Palm Springs.  I love this conference.  I always leave the conference on a super math high.  It is just the energy boost I need to get me through November and December and it leaves me with enough inspiration to make big changes in January.  It’s like they planned it that way…or something.

I have been teaching for just over a decade and I have attended CMC South every year.  Even when it wasn’t in the school budget I would find it in my personal budget to go.  I started my teaching career in a small, all-girls Catholic high school and found I did not have many people to collaborate with on best practices so I came to this conference hungry for information and inspiration.  In my early years I came to get “stuff”:  lesson plans, handouts, worksheets, already made items or detailed instructions on something I could do on Monday.  Now I come for inspiration.  I come to be reminded why I am in this profession, motivation to continue teaching math in spectacular ways, and for affirmation that what I am doing is meaningful and worthwhile.

CMC South did not disappoint this year.  I have never felt more energized and inspired to be a math teacher.  In fact, this CMC was different and probably the most memorable for me in all my years of attendance.  I was selfish with my time;  I only attended the sessions that truly served me and I took time to unpack things I heard and reflected on things I wrote down.  I had great company with me;  fellow math teachers, administrators, math coaches, and mathlebrities that were more than happy to discuss math education all day long.  And I had the opportunity to break bread with some incredible people in math education…I mean, when Robert Kasplinsky invites you to a dinner with #MTBoS peeps and you’re rubbing elbows with The Classroom ChefsNanette Johnson, and Dan Meyers it really makes you feel like you’re in the right place doing the right thing, am I right?!

cmc-math-2016

#MTBoS Dinner at CMC South.  Photo cred:  Meeeeeeeeeee!  Because I was there…NBD.

 

Now, I know this is not the experience everyone had at CMC.  This is not the experience I’ve had at every CMC.  Conversations during and after this conference with colleagues and friends confirmed this;  some have even said they wouldn’t come back because there’s just not value in the ideal picture that many of the presenters share.  The theory of math education just doesn’t translate well in a practical classroom (to put it nicely).  Some teachers walk away from these conferences with so little while my cup is overflowing.  Every experience is different, and that’s okay, but these conversations humbled me and made me wonder if I was really learning something from these conferences or if it was all just “fluff.”  Was my head was way to high up in the math clouds?  Was I going to come crashing down come Monday morning?

Then, I came across Matt Vaudrey’s blog.

He writes:

It’s easy to dream about big ideas, but some of the daily stuff is kicking my ass.

And worse than that; I’m feeling like the stuffed-shirt, overpaid, abstracted Educator that presents at conferences about ideas s/he hasn’t tried.

I’ve sat in those sessions and rolled my eyes and murmured to my teammate, “Aw, he’s a consultant.”

What can s/he possibly know about real teaching?

I am grateful for the experience I had at CMC.  I had the pleasure of attending Matt’s session at CMC and experienced a shift in my perspective about classroom culture.  It was very inspiring.  I can appreciate Matt’s vulnerability and humility in his post and I wondered if many consultants and math coaches feel this way often.  Especially the ones I’ve grown to respect and admire.

So, I wanted to write back to all the really good educational coaches and consultants out there:

Dear “…stuffed-shirt, overpaid, abstracted Educator…”,

You breathe new life into me every time I listen to you speak.  I need you to dream because I don’t always have time to dream.  If you don’t dabble in educational theory and share your discoveries with me, who will?  We need you to keep doing what you’re doing; because you’re good at it and you influence our classrooms in positive ways.

You’re what picks me up off the floor on the really tough days of teaching when everything feels like it’s going wrong.  You are who sets my gaze towards the prize of making a difference in my students’ lives.  You remind me why I got in this profession, renew my passion for teaching, and help me be the best for my students.  The ideals that you model are what helps me set goals for my own career and for my students.  I know I’m not going to reach those goals on the Monday after the conference but you motivate me to work towards them.

In short, thank you.  You make me think.  You make me wonder.  You make me great.  You make all of us great.

Success in a Math Classroom

I had my first formal observation today with my new principal.  Yesterday, I met with him and had my “pre-observation” meeting.  My principal asked me, “is there anything you want me to look out for tomorrow?”  And I responded with, “Well, I suck at first period.”  He laughed and told me this was normal;  assured me that it was because my students and me were still trying to get our rhythm that early in the day and it was understandable it wasn’t my best class.

blog-post_1

So, the perfectionist that I am, I stayed up late perfecting my lesson (not in a way that was different from my normal, but let’s be honest…best foot forward for this lesson, right?!)  I was excited and ready.  I made tons of notes of all the brilliant things I was going to do in class.  It was going to be great.  Here we go!

blog-post_2

The bell rings and I’m outside my door greeting my students.  They are getting new seats in their new teams so I had to hand them a random card that tells them where they sit in class.  Of course 40% of my students were super late so it made the start of class a little rough.  Then, my lesson did NOT go as planned (surprise, surprise…ugh!).  I had a student that was super off task that I had to prompt several times during the lesson.  Really?!  That kid could NOT figure out that Mr. Principal was in the room and act appropriately?!  Then, what was supposed to take only 15 minutes, the intro or warm-up to the lesson, took almost the whole class period.  This meant the amazing closure activity I had planned would not be relevant or meaningful to them!  I was bummed and very paranoid that I had not shown my principal “enough” of a lesson to evaluate me.

Second period bell rings.  It’s my prep so my principal sticks around a little to chat.  He said, “You’ve got to celebrate your successes!”

It was a great conversation;  positive and affirming in all the right ways.  He reminded me that success in my classroom means the student that got up in front of the class and explained perfectly how to use Pythagorean Theorem to the class;  success in my classroom means the argument he overheard two students having about the difference between intersecting and perpendicular lines;  success in my classroom means the girl that articulated so eloquently to the class how she figured out the slope of a segment.  And yeah, I didn’t get through the whole lesson but all of THAT happened in 1 class period.

He also reminded me that I teach the low-performing students.  My classes are primarily loaded with students that have traditionally struggled in math so they walk in the door already hating Geometry because it’s a math class.  He reminded me there are a slew of “intentional non-learners” that I am working with.  So, those students that stood up in front of their peers and spoke so beautifully about math are the ones who would have never done that before taking my class.  Those students would have never had arguments about math concepts before taking my class.  My class.  MY class.  I did that.  I facilitated that.  That is success in MY classroom.  It may not be pretty (like students that jump for joy at the idea of writing a proof!) but as they say, “beauty is in the eye of the beholder.”

This was a huge lesson that I needed to learn today because I feel like I fail as a teacher on the daily.  I know I’m my own worse critic and that failures can drive us to be better, but sometimes you just need an affirmation!  Maybe it’s because my definition of success and failure does not fit for my classroom.  In fact, success looks different in every teacher’s classroom.  What seemed so small to me, like a student getting up in front of the class and explaining something, was really a momentous occasion to be celebrated.

As educators, we have to find these successes, celebrate them, and then make them happen again and again.